Fresh Holiday Seafood to Cook at Home from Fulton Fish Market

Not everyone at the table reaches for turkey when it’s time to carve. For some, the true centerpiece of a meaningful holiday meal comes from the sea. There’s a certain luxury to seafood, it’s clean, elegant, and carries a kind of timelessness that suits Christmas Eve perfectly. From melt-in-your-mouth fillets to firm, flavorful steaks, seafood lovers know it isn’t just food, it’s a feeling. One that says this meal matters.

This season, choosing to serve seafood is more than a switch from tradition, it’s a way to offer something personal. Something a little more intentional. And with high-quality options shipped fresh from Fulton Fish Market, that offering becomes even more accessible. The market’s raw seafood selection gives you the freedom to create dishes that are thoughtful, quick to prepare, and tailored to those at your table who truly appreciate a good cut of fish.

To make planning easier, we’ve pulled together a list of premium raw picks from Fulton Fish Market, each paired with a quick recipe you can actually pull off between holiday errands and gift wrapping.

5 Raw Seafood Picks from Fulton Fish Market to Cook This Holiday

Before we get into what to cook, it’s worth knowing what you’re working with. Every product in this list is vacuum sealed to preserve freshness, making it easy to store in the fridge or freezer. Shipping is temperature-controlled, so everything arrives cold, clean, and ready to use. You can also choose your ideal delivery date at checkout, which makes holiday planning less of a guessing game.

For added flexibility, Fulton Fish Market also accepts installment payments through Afterpay and Shop Pay so stocking your kitchen with fresh seafood doesn’t have to mean one big upfront cost. Now, let’s dive into the standout selections worth serving this Christmas Eve.

Wild Atlantic Cod Portion - 1ct

Priced at $12.99 for a one time purchase or $12.34 with a subscription, this Wild Atlantic Cod Portion is one of those staples that earns its place in many Fulton Fish Market reviews. Sourced from the cold, clean waters around Iceland, this cut is known for its mild sweetness and firm white flesh that feels approachable even for hesitant home cooks. It carries none of the overpowering notes some people associate with seafood, which makes it a comfortable choice for holiday meals shared with mixed tastes. As part of the broader fulton seafood selection, the cod arrives vacuum sealed and ready to cook, fitting seamlessly into modern seafood delivery routines.

Quick Recipe Idea: Bake with olive oil, lemon slices, and butter at 400°F for 12 to 15 minutes until just flaky.

Branzino Fillet - 1ct

The Branzino Fillet sits at $18.99 for a one time purchase or $18.04 with a subscription, and it brings a refined touch to any holiday spread. Raised in nutrient rich Mediterranean waters, this fillet reflects the kind of thoughtful sourcing many shoppers look for when ordering seafood delivery for special occasions. As part of the curated Fulton seafood lineup, it feels elegant without being intimidating, making it ideal for Christmas Eve meals centered on lighter, cleaner flavors. Its subtle sweetness pairs well with simple seasonings, allowing the quality of the fish to shine through.

Quick Recipe Idea: Pan sear skin side down until crisp, then finish with garlic, capers, and a splash of white wine.

Fulton's Finest Wild Ahi Tuna Steak - 1ct

At $29.99 per portion, this Wild Ahi Tuna Steak is a bold choice for seafood lovers who appreciate rich texture and depth of flavor. Selected carefully by Fulton Fish Market fishmongers, this cut often appears in Fulton Fish Market reviews for its vibrant color and clean finish. As part of the premium fulton seafood offering, it is graded for quality that works beautifully for both quick sears and raw preparations, making it a versatile option during busy holidays. Delivered through temperature controlled seafood delivery, the steak arrives firm and ready for precise cooking. It’s a standout option for Christmas Eve meals that lean modern and minimal.

Quick Recipe Idea: Sear each side for 30 to 45 seconds, slice thin, and finish with soy sauce, sesame oil, and scallions.

Rainbow Trout Fillet - 1ct

Available for $10.99, with installment options through Afterpay or Shop Pay, the Rainbow Trout Fillet offers flexibility without sacrificing quality. Frequently mentioned in Fulton Fish Market reviews, trout appeals to those who enjoy salmon but prefer a lighter, softer texture. Raised responsibly and delivered fresh, this cut fits naturally into at home seafood delivery plans during the holidays. As part of the dependable fulton seafood range, it adapts well to different cooking styles while keeping prep simple. Its subtle flavor makes it a great choice for shared meals where balance matters more than boldness. For shoppers watching their holiday budgets, this is often a go to option when browsing Fulton Fish Market for reliable, everyday elegance.

Quick Recipe Idea: Roast with butter, fresh herbs, and lemon zest at 375°F for about 15 minutes until tender.

Fulton's Finest Atlantic Salmon Portion - 1ct

This Atlantic Salmon Portion is priced at $12.99 and remains a favorite across many Fulton Fish market reviews. Known for its smooth texture and gentle flavor, it suits both seasoned seafood fans and those newer to cooking fish at home. As part of the trusted fulton seafood selection, it is sourced from farms that prioritize consistency and quality, then shipped through reliable seafood delivery channels. The skin crisps nicely when cooked, adding texture without extra effort. During the holidays, salmon offers a familiar yet festive option for Christmas Eve tables that skip heavier dishes. Many shoppers check for a fulton fish market coupon when adding salmon to larger orders, especially when feeding family gatherings.

Quick Recipe Idea: Pan sear skin side down until crisp, flip briefly, and finish with honey, mustard, and fresh dill.

Choosing fresh seafood for the holidays is less about following tradition and more about honoring personal taste. With thoughtful sourcing, flexible purchasing options, and dependable seafood delivery, Fulton Fish Market makes it easier to build meals that feel intentional and memorable. Whether your table leans classic or contemporary, these raw selections invite creativity without complication, allowing the food to speak for itself.

As the premier partner of the Fulton Fish Market affiliate program, we would like to inform you that by tapping on the referral link, you may save big on your next purchase. We may earn a small commission without extra cost to you.

For more thoughtfully collected lifestyle content, follow OutdoorHues.